Well, James wasn't the only one who loved her
Lily had her share of suitors, too
When you're falling for your best friend's girl
There really isn't much you can do

So, I'm sorry that I'm not a perfect romance
Do me a favor, save me the last dance
So, I'm sorry that I'm not a perfect romance
Do me a favor, save the last dance for me

More than once, I've caught her stealing glances
We've more in common than they ever did
Both know there's chemistry, though we try to deny it
I wish I'd kissed her before that Potter kid

I played the good kid while Prongs managed mischief
A lot of good it did, you had eyes only for him
I know, I should have seen this coming
Your silver bullet tongue is what did my heart in

I don't wanna be a werewolf on Valentine's Day
It's so lonely being a werewolf on Valentine's Day

I don't wanna be alone on Valentine's Day
(I don't wanna be alone)
I don't wanna be alone on Valentine's Day
I don't wanna be alone on Valentine's Day

I don't wanna be alone…
So, Lily, won't you talk to me