In the garden of my Eden I was taken by surprise when the girl that I'd been seeing was caught in disguise.
Well I think I know, oh, why she would go.

On the first night that I met her, I could tell she was my type.
Then, she told me that she'd kissed the lips of girls I'd liked.
Well I think I know, oh, now why she would go.

'Cause I'm not the guy for you.
Maybe a girl will do.
It's too bad, too bad you were my type.

Your head was sure to pretend.
You were the boy's best friend.
Now you know, you know what it feels like.
Yes, you know what it feels like.

Yes, I want you and I need you, is what you had always said.
But the grass is always greener on another's bed.
Well I think I know, oh, why she would go.

But when you speak so softly 'bout the girls you love, it kills me.
I wanna know the names of every girl that takes you away.
So, will you love me like that?
(I will love you like that.)
But I can try and act.

'Cause I'm not the guy for you.
Maybe a girl will do.
It's too bad, too bad you were my type.

Your head was sure to pretend.
You were the boy's best friend.
Now you know, you know what it feels like.
Oh, no.