You haven't looked at me like that so long
We try to understand our rights from wrongs
Our eyes meet, and the glass already half gone
I know exactly what you're thinking 'bout
The train has left, the time has all run out
How can it feel so right if it's so wrong

Tell me when the time comes to go
When I'm with you I never know
My heart says stay, my head screams go
Heart over head
Heart over head

Still wear your hair the same way I remember
Still dance the same as when we were together
Our eyes meet, and the room's half disappeared
We said before, we couldn't break this off
It's from the heart, but it's still hard somehow
Let's push it off and pull me closer now

Tell me when the time comes to go
When I'm with you I never know
My heart says stay, my head screams go
Heart over head
Tell me when the time comes to go
When I'm with you I never know
My heart says stay, my head screams go
Heart over head
Heart over head
Heart over head

And I still won't let you go
I still can't let you go

Even when the time comes to go

Heart over head

Tell me when the time comes to go
When I'm with you I never know
My heart says stay, my head screams go
Heart over head