Loving you came easy, Carrie
Leaving you is, oh, so hard to do
Wishes come so easily
Wish I could stay with you

One heart's all I've got to give
Wish I could give to two
Everytime I think about her
She's the only one

Yet when I see your face
I can't erase
The dreams that just begun
I know it, Carrie, I would marry you

If I did not belong
Someone who is just like you
When love was just as strong
Carrie, please, believe me

Though I do what's right
Inside it feels so wrong
Oh I, just can keep you waiting
So I'm gonna say goodbye

But as the story ends
We'll say we're just friends
And though our love won't die
Believe me, Carrie, I would marry you

If I did not belong
Someone who was just like you
When love was just as strong
Carrie, I would marry you
Carrie, I would marry you