(One, two)

Well in the moment, you weren't all that kind
You with your wide-eyed grins, all I can see when I think of that time
Promises spoken, all coming back as lies
But you with your subsweet kiss is all I miss in the back of my mind

Did me wrong in the past
And I know it was bad

But you burn inside my memory so well
You caramel
You're caramel

Your cigarette-breath thick on your open mouth
Maple and amber clouds and coffee grounds when I think of it now
Oh, and all the nights with your friends around, ignoring me so they won't find out
You can act real cool 'cause it's over now, but, man, you cried when it all went down
And no one believed me, you gaslighted feelings
Still you had me thinking that I was the reason that I was fucking losing my mind

It was love at the worst
It was what we deserved

Yeah, you burn inside my memory so well
You caramel
You're caramel
And the longer the burn, the sweeter that you smell
You caramel
You're caramel

Sweet taste in my mouth
I can't get it out
I want you back now, and we're making out
Drunk, sleeping on my couch
Now when I hear you're in town, I just won't care about
Ooh-ooh, I heard you're in town
I want you back now
Come over to my house, there's space on my couch

Yeah, you burn inside my memory so well
You caramel
You're caramel